Skip to content

Female Genital Mutilation Is Child Abuse Too; So Why NO Enquiries About Ignoring It?

October 25, 2012

In May this year an e-petition demanding an end to female genital mutilation (FGM) in Britain was submitted to the UK Government website. I was lead author of that petition, which can be viewed here.
Well over 20,000, perhaps 25,000, under-age British girls are thought to be subjected to, or at serious risk of, FGM every year, so we might expect that a petition seeking to stop it would be accepted by the Government, as encouragement to action and greater awareness.

But no. The petition was, after a full week of waiting, rejected without explanation. It took another month or more of insistent emails to discover why.

No ‘professional neglect’?
Then at last it transpired that apparently there was discomfort in high places about the specific part of the e-petition which said:

Criminal abuse of children must not be ignored because those who enforce the law are uncertain how to deal with perpetrators and their victims.

This scandalous professional neglect, with 20,000+ children in the UK at risk, must be remedied forthwith. Full enforcement of the law must be brought to bear immediately.

The advice I eventually received was this:

It appears that it may be the phrase ‘professional neglect’ that is problematic, as it is potentially accusing unnamed individuals of criminal activity and could be seen as defamatory.

So the ‘offending’ phrase was removed and the petition published on 25 June 2012 as e-petition 35313: ‘Stop Female Genital Mutilation (FGM / ‘Cutting’) in Britain’.

Contrasting positions
Four months and hundreds of NoFGM e-petition supporting signatories later, many of us must be scratching our heads in bewilderment.

The sensitive souls in government required that a passing reference in the NoFGM e-petition to possible professional neglect, somewhere in a very crowded, non-person-specific field, be removed – even though there are many, many thousands of practitioners in health, social, legal and child safe-guarding roles in the UK and not even any particular occupation, let alone particular individual practitioners, was mentioned or named.

But now in contrast the hunt is on for a small number of people in a broadcasting company who may, or may not, have been complicit in the child abuse allegedly perpetrated by Jimmy Savile.

If found to be true, the allegations against Savile and anyone who shielded him in crime are indeed serious. It’s thought that perhaps 200 underage girls were victims over a number of years, and sadly some of them may very well have been traumatised with long term consequences.

We can however fervently hope that no-one suffered extreme pain, grim life-long physical damage or actually died – unlike the very much larger number of young girl victims of FGM (perhaps a quarter million over the decade, in Britain), some of whom will certainly have done so.

Some laws are not enforced; some may be
Procuring or perpetuating FGM in Britain, or on British children, carries a maximum (but not obligatory) penalty of 14 years in prison. It is also legally obligatory to report even any suspicion that a child is at risk or has undergone FGM.

Yet still there have been no successful prosecutions at all concerning anything to do with FGM, anywhere in the UK. ‘Too difficult…’ say the authorities.

The alleged child abuse by Savile and the possible culpability of BBC personnel currently make daily headline news, amid open discussion about possible prosecution of those who may at some point in the future be found to have failed to report their concerns about Savile’s activities to the authorities.

So why the coyness about people who fail to report or deal with suspicions about widespread and deadly breaches of the law on female genital mutilation?

A duty of child safe-guarding
If (in my view absolutely correctly) it’s now important to investigate a possible failure by third parties to protect children from abuse by the ‘entertainer’ Jimmy Savile, why was the far more impersonal e-petition on FGM apparently not permitted even to refer to the possibility of state-employed professionals neglecting children at risk of barbaric bodily harm?

Indeed, why did the current Coalition Government actually, actively, remove the role of national ‘NoFGM’ Co-ordinator, set up expressly to bring services together to stop this nightmarishly awful practice?

For the sake of all children, and specifically to halt the hurt to an estimated-average 50 children at risk or victims of female genital mutilation in Britain every day of the entire year, we must demand to know right now exactly who in child safe-guarding is responsible for what.

This article was also published in the Huffington Post of 25 October 2012.

~ ~ ~

Please sign the HM Government e-petition No.35313: Stop Female Genital Mutilation (FGM / ‘Cutting’) in Britain

You can read more about FGM and efforts to stop it here: #NoFGM: A Listing For Action & References On Female Genital Mutilation; or visit #NoFGM Daily News.

4 Comments leave one →
  1. Neil Emerton permalink
    October 27, 2012 00:23

    Thought you may like to know that the first prosecutions relating to FGM in Australia are coming up shortly. In all 4 people have been charged, including the parents, alleging FGM carried out on 2 young girls in NSW.

    In a separate case in WA, a couple have also been charged relating to sending a child to Indonesia for FGM.

    Our governments have been carrying out ‘education’ for nearly 20 years and the incidence is increasing. I have been advocating prosecutions for many years and look forward to the seeing the outcome of these first prosecutions.

    • October 27, 2012 08:14

      Thank you Neil. Yes, this is a very important development.

      We have in fact been following the news from Australia in our #NoFGM Daily News bulletin (which is available by subscription, free).

      If you have items you would like to see included in the bulletin, please tweet them with the hashtag #NoFGM and they will automatically appear in the next day’s edition.

      You might also like to add any really substantive research or developments as a Comment to follow this post: #NoFGM: A Listing For [UK] Action & References On Female Genital Mutilation, which is intended to be a more permanent point of reference for matters concerning FGM.

      Thanks again.

    • Neil Emerton permalink
      October 27, 2012 23:22

      Glad to see you are aware of the situation in Aus.

      I would like to see severe sentences imposed, to act as a deterant and to inform other immigrants that we insist on all abiding by our laws and social standards. However knowing the leniency of our courts, this is most unlikely and would be appealed, at our cost. The grounds of ‘culture’ is often used in our courts and they get away with it.

      It is a bit concerning that girls that had FGM performed on them years ago, are now having their own daughters done, such is the entrenchment of culture.

      I am also concerned about other cultural aspects we ‘turn a blind eye to’ such as forced marriages and violence between ethnics from age old hatreds. I am advocating a selective immigration programme that excludes those that have shown they cannot/will not integrate. Having a cohesive society is the aim.

      Thanks for your reply, this is a first step and we can only hope for a favourable outcome. I simply cannot comprehend how anyone can do FGM to a little girl.

  2. June 24, 2013 09:54

    Breakthrough! >> *NSPCC FGM HELPLINE* set up today, 24 June 2013

    Call: 0800 028 3550

    Female Genital Mutilation is child abuse. If you are worried a child may be a victim, or at risk of female genital mutilation don’t wait until you’re certain, contact the NSPCC immediately.

    In the UK, people from the following communities are most at risk of FGM:
    Bohra-Dawoodi (Pakistani and Indian)
    Sierra Leonean

    Don’t let socio-cultural pressures get in the way of protecting children.

    FGM is a harmful “cultural” practice, but it is not a religious one. Carrying out this practice has been a criminal offence in the UK since 1985. However, there has not been a single prosecution to date.

    As with other forms of child abuse, these crimes often remain hidden and unreported, as children are too ashamed or afraid to speak out.

    You can call the NSPCC helpline on 0800 028 3550 and send emails to, text on 88858 or use the NSPCC Helpline online form:

    More information on female genital mutilation here:

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: